The Giant Solar Storm of 2019
18 Jun 2019
Global decision Resolved

The Giant Solar Storm of 2019

Astronomers are offering a clear warning: a once-in-a-century solar storm is predicted to strike the Earth in the next six months. As with anything, nothing is unanimous. Some say they are being hysterical, others say we must prepare. Shielding transformers, satellites and data centres now would be expensive and thankless — if it works, nothing happens. Ignoring the warning is free, for six months. Do we harden the grid?

Opened 18 Jun 2019 Closed 12 Jul 2019 34 countries · 150 party votes

The choice

Option one

Harden the grid

  • — Engineers shield the transformers and satellites before the storm arrives
  • — If the forecasts are right, nothing will happen — and nobody will thank you
  • — Cost: 4% of GDP for 6 months 
20 of 34 countries chose this 58.8%
Option two Default if deadlocked

It's probably nothing

  • — The forecasts have been wrong before — and hardening the grid is expensive
  • — Nothing happens today — whatever the sky has in store is months away
  • — Industry: Technology growth -14 percentage points for 12 months, starting 90 days after the decision 
14 of 34 countries chose this 41.2%

The world's answer

49 Harden the grid 6 It's probably nothing 95 Abstained
150 party votes across 34 countries

World response

See how each country's parties responded to the decision.

Aftocratorianike

Harden the grid by majority
Harden the grid votes
1
party vote
It's probably nothing votes
0
party votes
Abstained
5
party votes

Party breakdown

1 vote recorded

“Nous nous devons d'écouter l'opinion d'experts, alors si les astronomes nous préviennent d'un potentiel danger, nous nous devons de nous y préparer.”

Voted July 9, 2019

Avalon

Harden the grid by majority
Harden the grid votes
5
party votes
It's probably nothing votes
0
party votes
Abstained
5
party votes

Party breakdown

4 votes recorded
The Gaia Syndicate Harden the grid

“We may get lucky, we may not. Either way, given the current climatic situation, we should be prepared for more extreme weather, even if it doesn't come right now”

Voted July 1, 2019
Left Alliance Harden the grid

“We should take the necessary actions to provide safety to oyr citizens”

Voted July 2, 2019

“Safety is essential for our nation. We must ensure it.”

Voted July 6, 2019
Democratic Group Harden the grid

“The lives and safety of our people is not something to gamble on. We should expand our defences not because a solar event is guaranteed, but because we cannot put financial costs over the lives of millions.”

Voted July 11, 2019

Azonia

Harden the grid by majority
Harden the grid votes
2
party votes
It's probably nothing votes
0
party votes
Abstained
2
party votes

Party breakdown

1 vote recorded
Levelup Azonia Harden the grid

“Preparing the country for the worst of situations.”

Voted June 18, 2019

Broadlands

It's probably nothing deadlock — default applied
Harden the grid votes
1
party vote
It's probably nothing votes
1
party vote
Abstained
6
party votes

Party breakdown

2 votes recorded
Liberal Freedom It's probably nothing

“We cannot afford this. It is probably nothing.”

Voted June 18, 2019
Liberal Front Harden the grid

“as civil servants, it's our duty to be prepared to every possible outcome, even the worst.”

Voted July 5, 2019

Charlemont

Harden the grid by majority
Harden the grid votes
3
party votes
It's probably nothing votes
1
party vote
Abstained
2
party votes

Party breakdown

4 votes recorded
Green-left Movement Harden the grid

“We should harden the grid now to reduce the risk of widespread damage and data loss, even if the event turns out to be less severe.”

Voted June 19, 2019
National Front It's probably nothing

“Our party believes that spending large amounts of public money on protection against a possible solar storm is not justified. Scientists have different opinions about how severe the effects could be, and there is no clear agreement that major disruption is likely. History has shown that some widely publicised risks have ended up causing far fewer problems than expected. Instead of investing in costly preventative measures, we believe governments should monitor the situation and respond if significant issues arise. Businesses that depend on vulnerable infrastructure should also take responsibility for protecting their own equipment.”

Voted June 23, 2019
Charlemont Unionists Harden the grid

“It is better to be safe and sorry. The economic costs of a solar storm would far outweigh anything spent to protect us here and now.”

Voted June 23, 2019
ALAYON Harden the grid

“If the Solar Storm indeed hits Earth, we must be prepared to avoid further damage and casualties.”

Voted June 29, 2019

Columbia

Harden the grid by majority
Harden the grid votes
4
party votes
It's probably nothing votes
0
party votes
Abstained
2
party votes

Party breakdown

3 votes recorded
Labour Harden the grid

“It is essential to take all measures against a possible threat, even though it might be a false alarm, better safe than sorry”

Voted June 18, 2019

“Prevention will be more cheaper than rebuilding Better safe than sorry”

Voted June 18, 2019

“We must protect our infrastructure doing nothing has high risk and no rewards”

Voted June 19, 2019

Costavela

Harden the grid by majority
Harden the grid votes
2
party votes
It's probably nothing votes
0
party votes
Abstained
2
party votes

Party breakdown

2 votes recorded

“Costavela is ready and the RSU is committed, whatever happens”

Voted June 19, 2019
Reform Costavela Harden the grid

“We need to protect our countries citizens, we cannot allow this storm to harm us.”

Voted June 22, 2019

Crowntopia

It's probably nothing deadlock — default applied
Harden the grid votes
0
party votes
It's probably nothing votes
0
party votes
Abstained
2
party votes

Party breakdown

0 votes recorded

No votes cast yet.

Drumagh

Harden the grid by majority
Harden the grid votes
1
party vote
It's probably nothing votes
0
party votes
Abstained
3
party votes

Party breakdown

0 votes recorded

No votes cast yet.

Elrondia

It's probably nothing deadlock — default applied
Harden the grid votes
0
party votes
It's probably nothing votes
0
party votes
Abstained
4
party votes

Party breakdown

0 votes recorded

No votes cast yet.

Holzminden

It's probably nothing deadlock — default applied
Harden the grid votes
0
party votes
It's probably nothing votes
0
party votes
Abstained
3
party votes

Party breakdown

0 votes recorded

No votes cast yet.

Javosca

It's probably nothing deadlock — default applied
Harden the grid votes
1
party vote
It's probably nothing votes
1
party vote
Abstained
2
party votes

Party breakdown

2 votes recorded
Red Green Labor Harden the grid

“We support this because we need to be strong”

Voted July 9, 2019
Populist Alliance It's probably nothing

“Javosca very simply cannot afford this in the current budget. We already run a deficit due to international earthquake aid and this would only worsen that debt”

Voted July 11, 2019

Kalpetia

It's probably nothing deadlock — default applied
Harden the grid votes
0
party votes
It's probably nothing votes
0
party votes
Abstained
3
party votes

Party breakdown

0 votes recorded

No votes cast yet.

Lavaria

It's probably nothing deadlock — default applied
Harden the grid votes
0
party votes
It's probably nothing votes
0
party votes
Abstained
4
party votes

Party breakdown

0 votes recorded

No votes cast yet.

Levonia

Harden the grid by majority
Harden the grid votes
1
party vote
It's probably nothing votes
0
party votes
Abstained
3
party votes

Party breakdown

1 vote recorded
Libra! Harden the grid

“This will probably cost us a lot of money but better safe than sorry.”

Voted June 25, 2019

Ludenholm

Harden the grid by majority
Harden the grid votes
3
party votes
It's probably nothing votes
0
party votes
Abstained
1
party vote

Party breakdown

3 votes recorded
Conservatives Harden the grid

“we must protect it if not for now then the future when it may happen again, it is an investment.”

Voted June 19, 2019
Communist Movement Harden the grid

“The government must listen to the scientists warnings and make the necessary investments to protect the people.”

Voted June 20, 2019

“Il faut se préparer et même faire de la prévention si ce n'est rien là maintenant.”

Voted July 8, 2019

Lysenne

It's probably nothing deadlock — default applied
Harden the grid votes
0
party votes
It's probably nothing votes
0
party votes
Abstained
3
party votes

Party breakdown

0 votes recorded

No votes cast yet.

Magna Taura

Harden the grid by majority
Harden the grid votes
1
party vote
It's probably nothing votes
0
party votes
Abstained
4
party votes

Party breakdown

1 vote recorded
Optimates Fasces Harden the grid

“Prevention is better than cure. That’s what we, Optimates, think.”

Voted June 25, 2019

Marianne

Harden the grid by majority
Harden the grid votes
1
party vote
It's probably nothing votes
0
party votes
Abstained
1
party vote

Party breakdown

1 vote recorded
The Greens Of Marianne Harden the grid

“Protecting the people of Marianne is our utmost priority, and is a policy that is taken with full commitment.”

Voted June 27, 2019

Northsea

It's probably nothing deadlock — default applied
Harden the grid votes
0
party votes
It's probably nothing votes
0
party votes
Abstained
3
party votes

Party breakdown

0 votes recorded

No votes cast yet.

Nova Artaris

Harden the grid by majority
Harden the grid votes
3
party votes
It's probably nothing votes
0
party votes
Abstained
4
party votes

Party breakdown

3 votes recorded

“It is better to be safe than sorry. While hardening the grid is expensive, if such a forecast is true then the cost to rebuild if we had done nothing will surely be more expensive than the costs we can incur to prepare today.”

Voted June 18, 2019
Imperial Nova Artaris Harden the grid

“Please happen. It's really just gambling, to be honest.”

Voted June 23, 2019

“We can go hard or go home. I'd rather go hard.”

Voted July 11, 2019

Novograd

It's probably nothing deadlock — default applied
Harden the grid votes
0
party votes
It's probably nothing votes
0
party votes
Abstained
2
party votes

Party breakdown

0 votes recorded

No votes cast yet.

Ostwaldreich

Harden the grid by majority
Harden the grid votes
1
party vote
It's probably nothing votes
0
party votes
Abstained
1
party vote

Party breakdown

1 vote recorded

“We need to take precautions. Just in case”

Voted July 3, 2019

Rheinland

Harden the grid by majority
Harden the grid votes
8
party votes
It's probably nothing votes
0
party votes
Abstained
2
party votes

Party breakdown

7 votes recorded

“You have to prepare for the worst. A little investment never hurts anyone.”

Voted June 19, 2019
Labour Movement Harden the grid

“Better safe than sorry. It will cost more to clean up the damage if the worst occurs.”

Voted June 21, 2019

“We must protect our selfs, we are so fragile, so this is manditory to save our selfs”

Voted June 23, 2019

“The well-being of citizens is paramount, even at high cost.”

Voted June 23, 2019

“The possible cost of fixing the grid once it's broken might be more expensive than the amount that we could pay for protecting it. It is in fact better safe than sorry.”

Voted June 23, 2019
Liberal Union Harden the grid

“4% of GDP is a hard pill to swallow, but for only six months, it is doable”

Voted July 1, 2019
Civic Platform Harden the grid

“HARDEN THE GRID!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!”

Voted July 6, 2019

Ronkonkoma

Harden the grid by majority
Harden the grid votes
1
party vote
It's probably nothing votes
0
party votes
Abstained
3
party votes

Party breakdown

1 vote recorded

“Let the weather don't destroy our country.”

Voted July 3, 2019

San Cordova

Harden the grid by majority
Harden the grid votes
1
party vote
It's probably nothing votes
0
party votes
Abstained
2
party votes

Party breakdown

1 vote recorded

“Better be safe than sorry so hardening the grid is a good idea”

Voted June 23, 2019

Saxenheim

Harden the grid by majority
Harden the grid votes
4
party votes
It's probably nothing votes
3
party votes
Abstained
1
party vote

Party breakdown

7 votes recorded

“We deeply respect scientists' work and inputs, and would never dare not to listen to them on scientifically-proven issues such as vaccines, energy sources or environment. This is a slightly different matter though. There's no unanimity between experts, and according to many the coming solar tempest will actually do little to no damage (just like all solar tempests before). We already have egregious examples of alarmism and, in some cases, fearmongering: the Y2K craze above all. As we all know, in the end nothing happened, proving wrong many an expert: it was partly because companies prepared, but in most cases clock issues was the worst consequence we experienced. Considering all this, and the prohibitive cost of mass shieldings, ADFR believes that nothing of significance will happen, and in the event it does, ex post facto analysis and intervention are a more appropriate way to deal with it. For what concerns private goods, companies are expected to protect their own assets.”

Voted June 21, 2019
Left Forward Harden the grid

“We cannot gamble with the infrastructure millions of people depend on every day. A major solar storm could threaten electricity, communications, hospitals, and essential public services. Even if this storm never strikes, a stronger and more resilient grid will be essential as we face increasingly extreme climate conditions and new challenges in the decades ahead. This is not wasted investment. It is preparation for the future. The cost of preparation is significant. The cost of doing nothing and being wrong would be immeasurable.”

Voted June 22, 2019
Competence And Freedom It's probably nothing

“Since there is no consesus on whether the solar storm could cause major damages, we consider that the extraordinarily high costs for such extensive preparations are not justified, especially considering that the budget is already under temporary strain after the recently approved earthquake relief.”

Voted June 25, 2019

“We believe that protecting Saxenheim’s infrastructure is a responsibility we cannot ignore. Our industries, communications, and essential services are the foundation of our nation, and we cannot risk leaving them vulnerable to a potential disaster. While hardening the grid will come at a cost, we believe that a strong nation prepares for the future rather than waiting for crisis to arrive. By investing now, we protect our workers”

Voted June 25, 2019
Christian Socials Harden the grid

“Well, we don't want to die, right? We HAVE to protect ourselvers. We're in great danger.”

Voted July 5, 2019
Homeland Alliance It's probably nothing

“We cannot afford this! Its probably a hoax”

Voted July 6, 2019
Saxenheim Republic Harden the grid

“We Cannot take risk on the infrastructures in which millions of people are depended. We believe hardening the grid would ensure the security of technology, communication, electricity and many more essential things of people in day to day life. a great country is always prepare for the worst so now let us invest in things that secures the infrastructure of saxenheim. so we support harden the grid”

Voted July 9, 2019

Sekuntomia

It's probably nothing deadlock — default applied
Harden the grid votes
0
party votes
It's probably nothing votes
0
party votes
Abstained
4
party votes

Party breakdown

0 votes recorded

No votes cast yet.

Solania

Harden the grid by majority
Harden the grid votes
2
party votes
It's probably nothing votes
0
party votes
Abstained
2
party votes

Party breakdown

2 votes recorded

“We must not show cowardice for our people and children when we are presented with information that tells us of potential danger towards them. We must ensure that no harm befalls upon them by all means necessary, no matter the expense!”

Voted June 19, 2019

“resiliance is key. If this rare event ends up being nothing then we prepare ourselves against other threats such as that posed by other nations, we increase our security and our asurance against threats to our grid no matter what.”

Voted June 23, 2019

Sveria

Harden the grid by majority
Harden the grid votes
1
party vote
It's probably nothing votes
0
party votes
Abstained
3
party votes

Party breakdown

1 vote recorded

“We cannot gamble with critical infrastructure. Preparing for a low-probability but high-impact event protects our economy, national security and citizens. Responsible governments invest in resilience before disasters, not after them.”

Voted June 18, 2019

Thornreach

It's probably nothing deadlock — default applied
Harden the grid votes
0
party votes
It's probably nothing votes
0
party votes
Abstained
4
party votes

Party breakdown

0 votes recorded

No votes cast yet.

Valmoire

It's probably nothing deadlock — default applied
Harden the grid votes
0
party votes
It's probably nothing votes
0
party votes
Abstained
2
party votes

Party breakdown

0 votes recorded

No votes cast yet.

Velinor

Harden the grid by majority
Harden the grid votes
2
party votes
It's probably nothing votes
0
party votes
Abstained
3
party votes

Party breakdown

2 votes recorded

“We are committed to a safe and secure Velinor. Thus, we must ensure that our country's infrastructure will not be impacted by any potential storms”

Voted June 25, 2019
Libertarian Left Harden the grid

“Of course we need to harden the grid! There is a solar storm coming!”

Voted July 4, 2019

Verdia

It's probably nothing deadlock — default applied
Harden the grid votes
0
party votes
It's probably nothing votes
0
party votes
Abstained
2
party votes

Party breakdown

0 votes recorded

No votes cast yet.

?
Game Wiki
Feature Roadmap
Bug report