“There isn't a single proposal ADFR can support. Mandatory ID cards are a "necessary evil": they're very useful, especially to enable our public administration to offer more and more digital services, but harvesting biometrics data's an extreme, dangerous and pointless measure. Likewise, easing guns control wouldn't bring anything good: data show that the more firearms circulate, the more the incidents and homicides. Finally, we cannot support the law-and-order measures either as they don't help our communities nor our companies, and only end up fanning distrust, discrimination and xenophobia.”
National Security And Sovereignty Act of 2020
Rationale
Strengthening national security, reducing gun violence, and optimizing public resources through streamlined identity verification and law enforcement.
Proposed Changes
| Law | Previous | Proposed | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | National Identity Cards |
Mandatory ID card
|
Mandatory biometric ID + central register
|
|
| 2 | Firearms Control |
Strict licensing, limited categories
|
Licensed ownership with background checks
|
|
| 3 | Asylum & Refugees |
Meet international obligations only
|
Strict processing, limited support
|
|
| 4 | Official Language Policy |
Multilingual rights guaranteed (core services available in multiple languages)
|
Single official language for all official documents and courts
|
|
| 5 | Deportation |
Case-by-case with full appeal rights
|
Firm enforcement with appeals
|
1
National Identity Cards2
Firearms Control3
Asylum & Refugees4
Official Language Policy5
DeportationProposer
Party
Homeland Alliance
A movement for citizens who believe that a nation's strength begins at home. The Homeland Alliance works to defend national interests, support hardworking families, and build a future based on stability, responsibility, and opportunity for all.
Core pillars
Karin Herrmann
Activist · Age 46
A reality TV star turned people’s champion, she parlays her celebrity into political influence, channelling working-class frustrations into a media-savvy crusade for traditional values and law and order.
Timeline
-
Draft1 April 2020
-
Vote Open1 April 2020
-
Vote Closed31 May 2020
-
Did Not Become Law31 May 2020
Vote tally
Live tally across each chamber. Weighted by seats held.
Bundesrat
FailedFor: 20 / 69 seats (29.0%)
Against: 47 · Abstained: 0 · Not voted: 2
| Party | Seats | Vote | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|
| Alliance For Digital Freedom And Rights | 14 | No | There isn't a single proposal ADFR can support. Mandatory ID cards are a "necessary evil": they're very useful, especially to enable our public administration to offer more and more digital services, but harvesting biometrics data's an extreme, dangerous and pointless measure. Likewise, easing guns control wouldn't bring anything good: data show that the more firearms circulate, the more the incidents and homicides. Finally, we cannot support the law-and-order measures either as they don't help our communities nor our companies, and only end up fanning distrust, discrimination and xenophobia. |
| Competence And Freedom | 12 | No | We cannot back this proposal in any form, it aims to reintroduce several policies we have argued and voted against in the past, such as stricter immigration and biometric data collection. |
| Homeland Alliance Proposer | 10 | Yes | No reason given |
| Left Forward | 21 | No | Needless to say, we cannot agree to this, as it would undermine our constitutional order. |
| Saxenheim Workers’ Union | 10 | Yes | A strong and secure nation requires effective systems for identification, public safety, and border management. Strengthening identity verification, maintaining responsible firearm regulation, enforcing immigration laws, and establishing a clear official language policy improves social cohesion, protects citizens, and ensures the state can operate efficiently. |
| Empty seats | 5 | Not voted |
Bundestag
FailedFor: 184 / 650 seats (28.3%)
Against: 446 · Abstained: 0 · Not voted: 20
| Party | Seats | Vote | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|
| Alliance For Digital Freedom And Rights | 130 | No | There isn't a single proposal ADFR can support. Mandatory ID cards are a "necessary evil": they're very useful, especially to enable our public administration to offer more and more digital services, but harvesting biometrics data's an extreme, dangerous and pointless measure. Likewise, easing guns control wouldn't bring anything good: data show that the more firearms circulate, the more the incidents and homicides. Finally, we cannot support the law-and-order measures either as they don't help our communities nor our companies, and only end up fanning distrust, discrimination and xenophobia. |
| Competence And Freedom | 117 | No | We cannot back this proposal in any form, it aims to reintroduce several policies we have argued and voted against in the past, such as stricter immigration and biometric data collection. |
| Homeland Alliance Proposer | 94 | Yes | No reason given |
| Left Forward | 199 | No | Needless to say, we cannot agree to this, as it would undermine our constitutional order. |
| Saxenheim Workers’ Union | 90 | Yes | A strong and secure nation requires effective systems for identification, public safety, and border management. Strengthening identity verification, maintaining responsible firearm regulation, enforcing immigration laws, and establishing a clear official language policy improves social cohesion, protects citizens, and ensures the state can operate efficiently. |
| Empty seats | 52 | Not voted |
Voting record
Every vote must state a public reason. Most recent first.
“Needless to say, we cannot agree to this, as it would undermine our constitutional order.”
“We cannot back this proposal in any form, it aims to reintroduce several policies we have argued and voted against in the past, such as stricter immigration and biometric data collection.”
“A strong and secure nation requires effective systems for identification, public safety, and border management. Strengthening identity verification, maintaining responsible firearm regulation, enforcing immigration laws, and establishing a clear official language policy improves social cohesion, protects citizens, and ensures the state can operate efficiently.”