Identity and Donation Reform of 2019
Proposed by Competence And Freedom
Failing
passing in 0 of 2 chambers
Opened
9 Jan 2019
Voting closes
10 Mar 2019
Chambers
2 legislatures
Articles
2 changes
Rationale
The proposed changes protect civil liberties by reducing mandatory data collection and ensuring organ donation respects individual choice and autonomy rather than assuming automatic consent.
Proposed Changes
| Law | Previous | Proposed | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | National Identity Cards |
Mandatory biometric ID + central register
|
Mandatory ID card
|
|
| 2 | Organ Donation |
Presumed consent, opt-out register
|
Explicit opt-in register
|
1
National Identity CardsPrevious law
Mandatory biometric ID + central register
Mandatory ID card
2
Organ DonationPrevious law
Presumed consent, opt-out register
Explicit opt-in register
Timeline
-
Draft9 January 2019
-
Vote Open9 January 2019
-
Vote Closed10 March 2019
-
Did Not Become Law10 March 2019
Vote tally
Live tally across each chamber. Weighted by seats held.
Bundesrat
Failed
11Yes
52No
6Not voted
69 seats
For: 11 / 69 seats (15.9%)
Against: 52 · Abstained: 0 · Not voted: 6
50.1% of those voting must vote in favour (actual = 17.5%)
| Party | Seats | Vote | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|
| Alliance For Digital Freedom And Rights | 11 | Yes | No reason given |
| Christian Socials | 0 | Yes | No reason given |
| Competence And Freedom Proposer | 0 | Yes | No reason given |
| Homeland Alliance | 29 | No | No reason given |
| Left Forward | 16 | No | No reason given |
| Modern Alliance Of Saxenheim | 7 | No | No reason given |
| Saxenheim Republic | 0 | No | No reason given |
| Empty seats | 5 | Not voted |
Bundestag
Failed
127Yes
466No
57Not voted
650 seats
For: 127 / 650 seats (19.5%)
Against: 466 · Abstained: 0 · Not voted: 57
50.1% of those voting must vote in favour (actual = 21.4%)
| Party | Seats | Vote | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|
| Alliance For Digital Freedom And Rights | 127 | Yes | No reason given |
| Christian Socials | 0 | Yes | No reason given |
| Competence And Freedom Proposer | 0 | Yes | No reason given |
| Homeland Alliance | 288 | No | No reason given |
| Left Forward | 134 | No | No reason given |
| Modern Alliance Of Saxenheim | 44 | No | No reason given |
| Saxenheim Republic | 0 | No | No reason given |
| Empty seats | 52 | Not voted |