Legislative Bill · Saxenheim
Failed

Child Labour Regulation Act of 2019

Failing
passing in 0 of 2 chambers
Opened
23 Aug 2019
Voting closes
22 Oct 2019
Chambers
2 legislatures
Articles
1 change

Rationale

This proposal Raises the minimum employment age to 18 protects children from exploitation, supports education, and ensures healthier development into adulthood. This proposal also ensures that the childrens are safe from exposing to harmfull jobs like working in hazardous factories and mines.

Proposed Changes

1

Child Labour Law
Previous law
Employment permitted from age 16 with restrictions; no work under 16
No employment of any kind until age 18

Timeline

  • Draft
    23 August 2019


  • Vote Open
    23 August 2019


  • Vote Closed
    22 October 2019


  • Did Not Become Law
    22 October 2019

Vote tally

Live tally across each chamber. Weighted by seats held.

Bundesrat

Failed
19Yes 40No 10Not voted 69 seats

For: 19 / 69 seats (27.5%)

Against: 40 · Abstained: 0 · Not voted: 10

50.1% of those voting must vote in favour (actual = 32.2%)
Party Seats Vote
Alliance For Digital Freedom And Rights 16 No
Competence And Freedom 8 No
Homeland Alliance 16 No
Left Forward 13 Yes
Monarchist Of Saxenheim Proposer 0 Yes
Saxenheim Republic 6 Yes
Saxenheim Workers’ Union 0 No
Empty seats 5 Not voted

Bundestag

Failed
179Yes 374No 97Not voted 650 seats

For: 179 / 650 seats (27.5%)

Against: 374 · Abstained: 0 · Not voted: 97

50.1% of those voting must vote in favour (actual = 32.4%)
Party Seats Vote
Alliance For Digital Freedom And Rights 151 No
Competence And Freedom 77 No
Homeland Alliance 146 No
Left Forward 126 Yes
Monarchist Of Saxenheim Proposer 0 Yes
Saxenheim Republic 53 Yes
Saxenheim Workers’ Union 0 No
Empty seats 52 Not voted

Voting record

Every vote must state a public reason. Most recent first.

Left Forward
Voted Aug. 25, 2019
Yes

“Childhood should be about learning, growing up and discovering the world, not earning a wage. Even where rules exist, young people can still face pressure to work instead of focusing on school. Raising the minimum employment age to 18 draws a clear line. Education comes first, and every child deserves the chance to finish it without economic pressure shaping their future.”

“Although the State needs to prevent exploitation, especially when minors are involved, we do not believe that raising the employment age to be the solution. There are already restrictions and safeguards in place: forbidding a 16 or 17 y.o. from working when they, for example, already left school or completed a vocational course, only increases the risk to encourage the plague of NEET. We obviously encourage our youth to study as much as possible but we cannot not take into account that some of them simply do not want to or are just not very academically inclined. For this reason, although we understand the noble intentions behind this bill, ADFR's voting against it.”

No

“Employment under appropriate conditions can teach responsibility, discipline, and valuable skills. Rather than banning all work until the age of 18, sensible regulations should protect young people from exploitation and hazardous occupations while still allowing them to gain experience and contribute to society.”

Competence And Freedom
Voted Aug. 24, 2019
No

“While constraining child labour is generally a noble idea, we believe that limiting the ability of the youth to perform work with restrictions actually hurts them by hampering their opportunities to make money during the summer break and accumulate potentially relevant job experience that will help them in the future.”

Homeland Alliance
Voted Aug. 24, 2019
No

“Early work keeps Teenagers out of crime. Keeping children permanently in education only leads to an educational bourgeoisie and the decline of important occupations in the craft sector. We have to oppose that. Teenagers should work as soon as they want to and are able to do so.”

Saxenheim Republic
Voted Aug. 23, 2019
Yes

“Children's are the tomorrow of our nation so we believe that increasing the age of minimum employment to 18 would ensure the health, good environment , supports education of children so saxenheim Republic supports this proposal for the good and healthier tomorrow”

?
Game Wiki
Feature Roadmap
Bug report