“We dont support this bill”
Defence And Civil Liberties Act of 2020
Rationale
These changes modernize laws to better balance freedoms with safety, reduce geopolitical risks, and align with public health best practices.
Proposed Changes
| Law | Previous | Proposed | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Nuclear Weapons |
Maintain a minimal deterrent
|
Retain weapons, pledge no first use
|
|
| 2 | Autonomous Weapons Systems |
Permitted with mandatory human control
|
Autonomous systems for defence only
|
|
| 3 | Arms Exports |
Licensed exports with end-use checks
|
Export only to close allies
|
|
| 4 | Tobacco & Vaping Regulation |
Heavy restrictions (plain packaging; indoor ban; age 21; advertising banned)
|
Light regulation (age 18, designated smoking areas, health warnings)
|
|
| 5 | Right to Protest |
Right to protest with prior notice
|
Right to protest with prior notice
|
1
Nuclear Weapons2
Autonomous Weapons Systems3
Arms Exports4
Tobacco & Vaping Regulation5
Right to ProtestProposer
Party
Marianne's Communist Front
A party based on democratic socialism and Eurocommunism. A party that helps workers, young people, and the less well-off.
Core pillars
Adrien Simon
Activist · Age 49
Raised in a cramped apartment above a machine shop, Adrien Simon clawed his way to the top of the political machinery with a ruthless efficiency, using his sharp mind and deep connections to dismantle opposition before it even forms.
Timeline
-
Draft14 January 2020
-
Vote Open14 January 2020
-
Vote Closed14 March 2020
-
Did Not Become Law14 March 2020
Vote tally
Live tally across each chamber. Weighted by seats held.
Senate
FailedFor: 147 / 348 seats (42.2%)
Against: 201 · Abstained: 0 · Not voted: 0
| Party | Seats | Vote | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|
| Marianne's Communist Front Proposer | 43 | Yes | No reason given |
| National Conservative Rally | 53 | No | We dont support this bill |
| The Greens Of Marianne | 104 | Yes | The Greens support the broadening of the freedom to protest and the disarmament of nuclear weapon production. |
| The Marianne Liberty Alliance | 69 | No | We oppose the provisions allowing for worse smoking laws exposing more to lethal addiction. |
| The National Refoundation Front | 79 | No | Under the guise of modernizing our laws, this bill sabotages the foundational sovereign pillars of our country and dangerously weakens Marianne's security. Making a unilateral "no first use" commitment regarding nuclear weapons and curbing our defense in the face of geopolitical threats is an unacceptable strategic error. Furthermore, restricting our arms exports suffocates our sovereign industry. Finally, even though easing the absurd restrictions on tobacco moves in the direction of a welcome individual freedom, it weighs nothing against the security and military danger this bill represents. The RNF will never compromise on the defense of the nation, the power of our armed forces, and the safety of citizens. We firmly reject this naive and destructive vision dictated by the far left! |
National Assembly
PassedFor: 330 / 577 seats (57.2%)
Against: 247 · Abstained: 0 · Not voted: 0
| Party | Seats | Vote | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|
| Marianne's Communist Front Proposer | 164 | Yes | No reason given |
| National Conservative Rally | 79 | No | We dont support this bill |
| The Greens Of Marianne | 166 | Yes | The Greens support the broadening of the freedom to protest and the disarmament of nuclear weapon production. |
| The Marianne Liberty Alliance | 57 | No | We oppose the provisions allowing for worse smoking laws exposing more to lethal addiction. |
| The National Refoundation Front | 111 | No | Under the guise of modernizing our laws, this bill sabotages the foundational sovereign pillars of our country and dangerously weakens Marianne's security. Making a unilateral "no first use" commitment regarding nuclear weapons and curbing our defense in the face of geopolitical threats is an unacceptable strategic error. Furthermore, restricting our arms exports suffocates our sovereign industry. Finally, even though easing the absurd restrictions on tobacco moves in the direction of a welcome individual freedom, it weighs nothing against the security and military danger this bill represents. The RNF will never compromise on the defense of the nation, the power of our armed forces, and the safety of citizens. We firmly reject this naive and destructive vision dictated by the far left! |
| Empty seats | 218 | Not voted |
Presidency
PassedFor: 1 / 1 seats (100.0%)
Against: 0 · Abstained: 0 · Not voted: 0
| Party | Seats | Vote | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|
| The Greens Of Marianne | 1 | Yes | No reason given |
Voting record
Every vote must state a public reason. Most recent first.
“The Greens support the broadening of the freedom to protest and the disarmament of nuclear weapon production.”
“We oppose the provisions allowing for worse smoking laws exposing more to lethal addiction.”
“Under the guise of modernizing our laws, this bill sabotages the foundational sovereign pillars of our country and dangerously weakens Marianne's security. Making a unilateral "no first use" commitment regarding nuclear weapons and curbing our defense in the face of geopolitical threats is an unacceptable strategic error. Furthermore, restricting our arms exports suffocates our sovereign industry. Finally, even though easing the absurd restrictions on tobacco moves in the direction of a welcome individual freedom, it weighs nothing against the security and military danger this bill represents. The RNF will never compromise on the defense of the nation, the power of our armed forces, and the safety of citizens. We firmly reject this naive and destructive vision dictated by the far left!”