Legislative Bill · Marianne
Failed

Data Harvesting Ban Act of 2009

Proposed by Assemble For The Republic! · fronted by Marie François
Failing
blocked by Presidency
Opened
23 Jul 2009
Voting closes
21 Sep 2009
Chambers
2 legislatures
Articles
4 changes

Rationale

Citizens must be protected from corporate, government, and private surveillance of any kind. This means protecting the internet from surveillance, protecting people from being surveilled in the streets and their homes, and providing channels for all citizens to watch on television. Freedom of info!

Proposed Changes

1

Data Privacy & Digital Rights
Previous law
Basic data protection (consent required; breach notification; opt-out rights)
Strict data rights (right to deletion; algorithmic transparency; heavy fines for violations)

2

Internet Freedom
Previous law
Moderate regulation (illegal content removed; platforms must verify age; data rules enforced)
Light-touch regulation (net neutrality; limited takedown orders for serious crime only)

3

Public Broadcasting Funding
Previous law
Limited public broadcaster (news/education remit; funded by small household levy)
Major public broadcaster (multi-channel; ad-free; funded by general taxation)

4

State Surveillance Powers
Previous law
Targeted surveillance (court order required; independent oversight commissioner)
Strict privacy protections (right to encryption; no bulk data collection; facial recognition banned)

Timeline

  • Draft
    23 July 2009


  • Vote Open
    23 July 2009


  • Vote Closed
    21 September 2009


  • Did Not Become Law
    21 September 2009

Vote tally

Live tally across each chamber. Weighted by seats held.

Senate

Passed
184Yes 118No 46Not voted 348 seats

For: 184 / 348 seats (52.9%)

Against: 118 · Abstained: 0 · Not voted: 46

50.1% of those voting must vote in favour (actual = 60.9%)
Party Seats Vote
Assemble For The Republic! Proposer 85 Yes
Union Blue & Rouge 118 No
United Imperial Alliance 99 Yes

National Assembly

Passed
306Yes 236No 35Not voted 577 seats

For: 306 / 577 seats (53.0%)

Against: 236 · Abstained: 0 · Not voted: 35

50.1% of those voting must vote in favour (actual = 56.5%)
Party Seats Vote
Assemble For The Republic! Proposer 136 Yes
Union Blue & Rouge 236 No
United Imperial Alliance 170 Yes

Presidency

Failed
0Yes 1No 0Not voted 1 seat

For: 0 / 1 seats (0.0%)

Against: 1 · Abstained: 0 · Not voted: 0

Passes unless the office holder votes against (abstention counts as pass)
Party Seats Vote
Union Blue & Rouge 1 No

Voting record

Every vote must state a public reason. Most recent first.

No votes cast yet.

?
Game Wiki
Feature Roadmap
Bug report