Charlemont
Proposals
Public Healthcare System Reform of …

Legislative Bill · Charlemont

Public Healthcare System Reform of 2019

Proposed by Social Democratic · fronted by Mathieu Robin

Opened

30 Oct 2019

Voting closes

29 Dec 2019

Chambers

2 legislatures

Articles

1 change

Rationale

We should guarantee our citizens a universal free healthcare system, although the one we have in theory it provides it, but we have to amplify the system so that the waiting lists for operations are reduced and the peoples health are safeguarded by the State, without private hands.

Proposed Changes

	Law	Previous		Proposed
1	Healthcare System Model	Public system with private top-ups		Single public system, free at point of use

1

Healthcare System Model

Previous law

Public system with private top-ups

Single public system, free at point of use

Proposer

Party

Social Democratic

A party dedicated to everyone, its voters and not, the elderly and the youth, that doesnt leave anyone behind. We defend LGBTIQ+ rights, a mix of a welfare system and promotion of small and middle businesses and the protection of every citizen and their rights, as women, historically left behind

Core pillars

Mathieu Robin

Activist · Age 31

113,949 social followers

A rising star in policy circles, Mathieu Robin cut his teeth in think tanks before climbing the party ranks with his sharp intellect and well-placed connections, though his pragmatism occasionally frustrates idealists.

🎓 Academic 🤝 Loyal 📺 Media Savvy ⚖️ Pragmatist 🔗 Well Connected

Timeline

Draft

30 October 2019
Vote Open

30 October 2019
Vote Closed

29 December 2019
Did Not Become Law

29 December 2019

Vote tally

Live tally across each chamber. Weighted by seats held.

Senate

Failed

33Yes 102No 59Abstained 154Not voted 348 seats

For: 33 / 348 seats (9.5%)

Against: 102 · Abstained: 59 · Not voted: 154

50.1% of those voting must vote in favour (actual = 24.4%)

Party	Seats	Vote	Reason
ALAYON	59	Abstain	We respectfully abstain. Thank you
National Front	102	No	National Front agrees that we should try to improve Healthcare, but if we remove the private sector from healthcare and remove all charges, then quality dips and new hospitals stop being built. To pass this while continuing to build hospitals & clinics, and not dropping quality significantly, we would need a huge hike in healthcare spending, and we just can’t afford it.
Social Democratic Proposer	33	Yes	No reason given
Empty seats	14	Not voted

National Assembly

Failed

41Yes 187No 67Abstained 282Not voted 577 seats

For: 41 / 577 seats (7.1%)

Against: 187 · Abstained: 67 · Not voted: 282

50.1% of those voting must vote in favour (actual = 18.0%)

Party	Seats	Vote	Reason
ALAYON	67	Abstain	We respectfully abstain. Thank you
National Front	187	No	National Front agrees that we should try to improve Healthcare, but if we remove the private sector from healthcare and remove all charges, then quality dips and new hospitals stop being built. To pass this while continuing to build hospitals & clinics, and not dropping quality significantly, we would need a huge hike in healthcare spending, and we just can’t afford it.
Social Democratic Proposer	41	Yes	No reason given
Empty seats	17	Not voted

Presidency

Failed

0Yes 1No 0Not voted 1 seat

For: 0 / 1 seats (0.0%)

Against: 1 · Abstained: 0 · Not voted: 0

Passes unless the office holder votes against (abstention counts as pass)

Party	Seats	Vote	Reason
National Front	1	No	No reason given

Voting record

Every vote must state a public reason. Most recent first.

National Front

Voted Dec. 20, 2019

“National Front agrees that we should try to improve Healthcare, but if we remove the private sector from healthcare and remove all charges, then quality dips and new hospitals stop being built. To pass this while continuing to build hospitals & clinics, and not dropping quality significantly, we would need a huge hike in healthcare spending, and we just can’t afford it.”

ALAYON

Voted Nov. 17, 2019

Abstain

“We respectfully abstain. Thank you”