Charlemont
Proposals
Organ Donation Consent Reform of …

Legislative Bill · Charlemont

Organ Donation Consent Reform of 2020

Proposed by National Front · fronted by Étienne Henry

Opened

30 Oct 2020

Voting closes

29 Dec 2020

Chambers

2 legislatures

Articles

1 change

Rationale

Increasing organ shortages need urgent solutions. Presumed consent with opt-out maximizes transplants to save lives.

Proposed Changes

	Law	Previous		Proposed
1	Organ Donation	Donation only with family consent		Presumed consent, opt-out register

1

Organ Donation

Previous law

Donation only with family consent

Presumed consent, opt-out register

Proposer

Party

National Front

We support National Pride, Strict Immigration Laws, Investment in Law Enforcement, Agriculture & Mining, Domestic Oil & Gas Extraction, and Limited Red & Green Tape for businesses.

Core pillars

ÉH

Étienne Henry

Minister for Foreign Affairs · Age 51

150,459 social followers

Once a rousing union agitator turned political provocateur, Étienne Henry captivates audiences with his electrifying speeches, blending radical demands with sharp data-driven critiques of the status quo.

🔬 Analytical ✨ Charismatic 🎤 Fantastic Speaker 🔥 Firebrand

Timeline

Draft

31 August 2019
Vote Open

30 October 2020
Vote Closed

29 December 2020
Became Law

29 December 2020

Vote tally

Live tally across each chamber. Weighted by seats held.

Senate

Passed

141Yes 0No 207Not voted 348 seats

For: 141 / 348 seats (40.5%)

Against: 0 · Abstained: 0 · Not voted: 207

50.1% of those voting must vote in favour (actual = 100.0%)

Party	Seats	Vote	Reason
Conservative Craft	0	No	No, I believe organ donation should require explicit consent. While saving lives is important, I believe presumed consent could reduce public trust in hospitals and create concerns that organ recovery is prioritized over lifesaving care. Protecting patient trust and informed consent should come first.
National Front Proposer	141	Yes	No reason given
The Liberal Socialista	0	No	The should not be any such thing as "presumed consent". Any sort of modification to a persons body without their or their family s explicit consent should be illegal
Empty seats	14	Not voted

National Assembly

Passed

252Yes 104No 221Not voted 577 seats

For: 252 / 577 seats (43.7%)

Against: 104 · Abstained: 0 · Not voted: 221

50.1% of those voting must vote in favour (actual = 70.8%)

Party	Seats	Vote	Reason
Conservative Craft	0	No	No, I believe organ donation should require explicit consent. While saving lives is important, I believe presumed consent could reduce public trust in hospitals and create concerns that organ recovery is prioritized over lifesaving care. Protecting patient trust and informed consent should come first.
National Front Proposer	252	Yes	No reason given
The Liberal Socialista	104	No	The should not be any such thing as "presumed consent". Any sort of modification to a persons body without their or their family s explicit consent should be illegal
Empty seats	17	Not voted

Presidency

Passed

1Yes 0No 0Not voted 1 seat

For: 1 / 1 seats (100.0%)

Against: 0 · Abstained: 0 · Not voted: 0

Passes unless the office holder votes against (abstention counts as pass)

Party	Seats	Vote	Reason
National Front Proposer	1	Yes	No reason given

Voting record

Every vote must state a public reason. Most recent first.

Conservative Craft

Voted Nov. 2, 2020

“No, I believe organ donation should require explicit consent. While saving lives is important, I believe presumed consent could reduce public trust in hospitals and create concerns that organ recovery is prioritized over lifesaving care. Protecting patient trust and informed consent should come first.”

The Liberal Socialista

Voted Oct. 30, 2020

“The should not be any such thing as "presumed consent". Any sort of modification to a persons body without their or their family s explicit consent should be illegal”