National Identity Card Mandate of 2021 - Belvaria

Rationale

La carte d'identité est essentielle pour les différents contrôles. Cela est important car il faut pouvoir prouver son identité de manière simple et rapide.

Proposed Changes

	Law	Previous		Proposed
1	National Identity Cards	Voluntary ID card		Mandatory ID card

1

National Identity Cards

Previous law

Voluntary ID card

Mandatory ID card

Proposer

Party

Alliance Rn

Le parti est un parti d’extrême droite.Ce parti se situe entre extrême droite et droite républicaine

Core pillars

KF

Karl Fischer

Activist · Age 31

9,270 social followers

A former high-finance operative, Karl Fischer leveraged his analytical mind and media savvy to expose corruption before turning his ruthless tactics toward reshaping the political landscape.

🔬 Analytical 🏦 Former Banker 📺 Media Savvy 🌍 Outsider 🗡️ Ruthless

Timeline

Draft

28 January 2021
Vote Open

31 January 2021
Withdrawn

31 January 2021
Never Became Law

31 January 2021

Vote tally

Live tally across each chamber. Weighted by seats held.

Federal Council

Failed

0Yes 0No 70Not voted 70 seats

For: 0 / 70 seats (0.0%)

Against: 0 · Abstained: 0 · Not voted: 70

50.1% of those voting must vote in favour (actual = 0.0%)

Party	Vote	Reason
Alliance Rn Proposer	Yes	Avoir une preuve de son identité est importante.
Liberal	No	This is bad for freedom
Liberty For Belvaria!	No	A clear deprivation of liberties from the government. A person should be allowed to opt out of an ID card, for personal reasons or otherwise, having accepted the consequences and effects it may entail on their lives.
Together We Can	No	We oppose this law. Voluntary ID already lets citizens who want one get one, without turning identification into a tool that historically gets used disproportionately against the poor, immigrants, and marginalized communities. We stand against expanding state tracking infrastructure without clear justification

National Parliament

Failed

0Yes 0No 500Not voted 500 seats

For: 0 / 500 seats (0.0%)

Against: 0 · Abstained: 0 · Not voted: 500

50.1% of those voting must vote in favour (actual = 0.0%)

Party	Seats	Vote	Reason
Alliance Rn Proposer	0	Yes	Avoir une preuve de son identité est importante.
Liberal	0	No	This is bad for freedom
Liberty For Belvaria!	0	No	A clear deprivation of liberties from the government. A person should be allowed to opt out of an ID card, for personal reasons or otherwise, having accepted the consequences and effects it may entail on their lives.
Together We Can	0	No	We oppose this law. Voluntary ID already lets citizens who want one get one, without turning identification into a tool that historically gets used disproportionately against the poor, immigrants, and marginalized communities. We stand against expanding state tracking infrastructure without clear justification
Empty seats	73	Not voted

Federal Chancellor

Passed

0Yes 0No 1Not voted 1 seat

For: 0 / 1 seats (0.0%)

Against: 0 · Abstained: 0 · Not voted: 1

Passes unless the office holder votes against (abstention counts as pass)

President

Passed

0Yes 0No 1Not voted 1 seat

For: 0 / 1 seats (0.0%)

Against: 0 · Abstained: 0 · Not voted: 1

Passes unless the office holder votes against (abstention counts as pass)

Voting record

Every vote must state a public reason. Most recent first.

Liberty For Belvaria!

Voted Jan. 31, 2021

No

“A clear deprivation of liberties from the government. A person should be allowed to opt out of an ID card, for personal reasons or otherwise, having accepted the consequences and effects it may entail on their lives.”

Liberal

Voted Jan. 31, 2021

No

“This is bad for freedom”

Together We Can

Voted Jan. 31, 2021

No

“We oppose this law. Voluntary ID already lets citizens who want one get one, without turning identification into a tool that historically gets used disproportionately against the poor, immigrants, and marginalized communities. We stand against expanding state tracking infrastructure without clear justification”

Alliance Rn

Voted Jan. 31, 2021

Yes Changed vote

“Avoir une preuve de son identité est importante.”